2009년 5월 6일 수요일

Is it art?

John Cage is famous for his performance "4 min. 33sec." in which he walked into the stage and decorated it with absolute silence for 4 minute and 33 seconds. The piece is seen as challenging the very definition of music. The definition of art, however, is the process of deliberately arranging elements in a way that appeals to the senses of emotions(according to the Wikipedia). And from my point of view, John Cage's "4min. 33sec" is definitely a piece of art.Even though the piece has no particular rhythm or melody, and it cannot be precisely defined as music, it was a performance that consisted of the artist's intention to make the audience feel something through listening to the trifle noises.John Cage says that he spent many hours conducting performances of his silent pieces, and I strongly believe that his effort to appeal to the audience itself is a great work.Also, I believe that sometimes an accidental thing can end up as a beautiful artpiece. There are many examples that show the beauty of improvisation in art, including Action painting, and Chance music and so on. Therefore, although the durations were filled with unpredictable noises that came from the audience, "4min 33 sec" should be regarded as an artpiece.Cage wished the audience to listen to the sounds of themselves, and get fresh feelings from it. I'm sure he succeeded in doing so in the form of art. Thus, I believe his novel creativity should be acknowledged its artistic price.

댓글 11개:

  1. 작성자가 댓글을 삭제했습니다.

    답글삭제
  2. Hello I'm byung min may be it is the first comment right? your essay quite long;;;.....
    I want you to visti my blog, too BYE~~~:)

    답글삭제
  3. The Kim Sumi teacher has ordered me to write a comment on this piece. Be warned that this is not my real intention nor is this comment my opininon.
    Personally- as a person who performed the 4min 33sec -I don't accept the 4min 33sec is art, for it is completely frustrating to just stay up on the stage without making a sound. There is no sensation of music in the 4min 33sec, but simple frustration as the crowd begin to murmur, wondering if the guy on the stage is insane.

    답글삭제
  4. Wow! Jahyeon kwon~
    Wonderful!
    I was very impressed by 'Cage wished the audience to listen to the sounds of themselves, and get fresh feelings from it.'.
    Actually, I didn't think about his deep intention and effort on his art.
    You gave me fresh shock!! ♥♥♥

    답글삭제
  5. You insisted your opinion with great example and defined about art with reliable web site. Therefore I think you did a good job!

    답글삭제
  6. I think like that too.
    Your writing have very powerful opinion.
    I really impressed.

    답글삭제
  7. wow
    great job!
    ive always known that u were this good
    but still good job^^!

    답글삭제
  8. 작성자가 댓글을 삭제했습니다.

    답글삭제
  9. Hello! Jahyeon.

    I was impressed with your writing. Also I have same thinking with you. Even if he didn't react anything, it is kind of art.

    답글삭제
  10. Jahyeon!! Can you guess who am I? LOL

    Anyway, your essay is great! I envy you and also agree with your opinion. The art is not defined thing, isn't it?

    답글삭제